Modified on: April 2024

How Woodford exploited the fundamental flaw in fund shortlists

The story of active management and Neil Woodford

This article on Neil Woodford originally featured as a guest post on Gentleman’s Family Finances.

Every active manager has a story to tell about how they will outperform the market. Neil Woodford is no different. He believed that he could continue his winning streak by investing in companies that were overlooked and undervalued.

To help spread the story, Woodford teamed up with Hargreaves Lansdown, arguably the most influential storyteller in the UK. In exchange for selling his story to millions of investors, Woodford gave Hargreaves customers a discount to invest in his fund. In return, Hargreaves included his fund in their ‘Wealth 50’ list and encouraged investors to buy.

Fund shortlists

The Wealth 50 list is a shortlist of their experts favourite funds, a type of best buy list. They’ll tell you that it “isn’t personal advice”, simply a way to narrow the list of more than 3,000 available funds.

But speak to any Hargreaves customer and they’ll paint a very different picture. They’ll say things like, “I invested mainly because Hargreaves Lansdown was promoting it so much and hailing Woodford as a star investor”.

And that’s the problem. Hargreaves may not have been providing advice, but its customers didn’t see it that way. They felt that Hargreaves was making a “recommendation”, which they trusted and invested accordingly.

The fundamental flaw

Although best buy lists may have good intentions, there’s a fundamental flaw – what’s good for the platform/manager isn’t always good for the investor.

By including Woodford in the Wealth 50 list, Hargreaves secured a sizable discount for its customers. Naturally, having access to lower-cost funds meant that more money flowed in.

But when Woodford soured, he was kept in the Wealth 50 list.  They continued to promote the fund, despite poor performance. If Hargreaves truly believed Woodford was worth keeping, why did their Multi-Manager portfolios sell down the fund, whilst continuing to promote it?

It’s obvious. They knew that Woodford was a bad investment, but there was a commercial incentive to keep him on the list. In fact, they had concerns about the fund’s liquidity as far back as 2017, but nothing was done about it. As a result, thousands of investors have lost their hard-earned savings.

As an industry, what we’ve done is attempted to get people interested in investing by creating shortcuts in the form of best buy lists. But let’s be frank, shortcuts are designed by experts and used by amateurs. The average investor was generally uninformed about the risks of the Woodford fund, and when things went downhill, they relied on the shortcut they knew, the best buy list.

When best buy lists are designed for profit, rather than for the customers benefit, the customer will inevitably get burnt.

What can be done to prevent the next Woodford scandal?

So what can we learn and what should we do?

For starters, there needs to be greater regulatory oversight of best buy lists. Regulation should focus on protecting the customer from potential conflicts of interest. With such influence, a small statement at the bottom of the page telling you that your money is at risk doesn’t quite cut it.

We should also be wary of placing too much faith in the skills of any star manager. The best thing an investor can do is place their money in a well-diversified, low-cost index-tracking fund. Failing that, they should never buy a fund named after someone (there’s just too much ego).

If there’s one benefit to this whole saga it may be that customers come to appreciate that past performance really is no indication of future performance.

All the best,

James Mackay, Independent Financial Adviser in Bristol



Financial Advisor Bristol and Pension Advisor Clifton

Frazer James Financial Advisers is an Independent Financial Advisor Bristol, Clifton.

About us: Frazer James Financial Advisers is a financial advisor, based in Clifton, Bristol. As an independent financial adviser, we’re able to provide independent and unbiased financial advice. We provide independent financial advice, pension advice, investment advice, inheritance tax planning and insurance advice.

If you would like to speak to a Financial Advisor, we offer an Initial Financial Consultation without cost or commitment. Meetings are held either at our offices, by video or by telephone. Our telephone number is 0117 990 2602.

Frazer James Financial Advisers is located at Square Works, 17 – 18 Berkeley Square, Bristol, BS8 1HB.

This article provides information about investing, but not personal advice. If you’re not sure which investments are right for you, please request advice.

Remember that investments can go up and down in value, you may get back less than you put in.

Related news

Arrow link
Arrow link
lady having a free meeting with a financial planner

Get in touch

Schedule a free consultation with one of our financial advisers, or give us call.

0117 990 2602